Strategy GuidePublished: January 23, 2025• 12 min readComing Soon

Scalping vs Day Trading:
Which Strategy for Prop Firms?

Choosing between scalping and day trading can make or break your prop firm success. This guide compares both strategies, reveals which firms allow scalping, and helps you identify which approach fits your personality and goals.

Introduction: Two Different Worlds

📝 Content Coming Soon

  • • The fundamental difference between scalping and day trading
  • • Why prop firms care about your trading style
  • • Time commitment and screen time requirements
  • • Personality traits that suit each strategy

Scalping Explained

📝 Content Coming Soon

  • • Definition: holding trades for seconds to minutes
  • • Typical profit targets: 5-20 ticks/pips per trade
  • • Trade frequency: 20-100+ trades per day
  • • Best markets for scalping (futures, forex pairs)
  • • Required tools: Level 2 data, DOM, fast execution
  • • Pros: Quick feedback, limited exposure, high win rates
  • • Cons: High commissions, mental fatigue, platform dependency

Day Trading Explained

📝 Content Coming Soon

  • • Definition: holding trades for minutes to hours (close by EOD)
  • • Typical profit targets: 1:2 to 1:3 risk-reward
  • • Trade frequency: 1-10 trades per day
  • • Best markets for day trading (stocks, indices, forex)
  • • Required tools: Charts, indicators, news feeds
  • • Pros: Lower stress, better R:R, fewer commissions
  • • Cons: Longer drawdown periods, need patience, overnight gaps

Head-to-Head Comparison

📝 Content Coming Soon - Comparison Table

  • • Time per trade: Scalping (30 sec - 5 min) vs Day Trading (15 min - 4 hours)
  • • Trades per day: Scalping (20-100+) vs Day Trading (1-10)
  • • Win rate: Scalping (60-80%) vs Day Trading (40-55%)
  • • Risk-reward: Scalping (1:1 to 1:1.5) vs Day Trading (1:2 to 1:3)
  • • Commission impact: Scalping (HIGH) vs Day Trading (LOW)
  • • Stress level: Scalping (VERY HIGH) vs Day Trading (MODERATE)
  • • Screen time: Scalping (6-8 hours) vs Day Trading (2-4 hours)

Which Prop Firms Allow Scalping?

📝 Content Coming Soon

  • Scalping-Friendly: Apex Trader Funding, TopStep, E8 Funding
  • Restrictions: FTMO (limited scalping), MyForexFunds
  • Best execution: Firms offering Rithmic/CQG platforms
  • • Commission structures and how they affect scalpers
  • • News trading rules and scalping during high volatility

Capital Requirements

📝 Content Coming Soon

  • • Minimum account size for scalping effectively
  • • Minimum account size for day trading
  • • Commission costs comparison over 100 trades
  • • Slippage impact on scalping vs day trading
  • • Recommended challenge sizes for beginners

Which Strategy Should You Choose?

📝 Content Coming Soon - Decision Framework

  • • Choose scalping if: High energy, love action, can focus 6+ hours
  • • Choose day trading if: Patient, analytical, prefer quality over quantity
  • • Personality quiz: Which strategy matches your temperament
  • • Hybrid approach: Combining both strategies
  • • How to test which works for you (demo account strategies)

Find Firms That Match Your Strategy

Compare prop firms based on their scalping policies, execution speed, and commission structures.

Compare Prop Firms